Who’s More Frugal? Me vs. Mr. Extreme Saver

Last week, one of our guest bloggers, Mr. Extreme Saver posted a great blog post about how he is able to live in NYC on only a $1k a month of spending. That got me thinking. A lot of spending consists of “trying to keep up with the Joneses.” But what if instead of competing on how much we can spend (which is a lose-lose scenario), we were to compete on how little we spend? Here is my budget and how I stack up to Mr. Extreme Saver:

Housing: By living with not one but two roommates, I’m able to keep my rent down to $575 a month. Utilities only add about an extra $36 a month since I live in an apartment in San Diego (lower heating costs and no air conditioning) and split the bills 3 ways with my roommates. Household expenses like kitchen and bathroom supplies tack on a few more dollars for a total of around $650 per month. While most unmarried people want to live alone, I actually prefer living with roommates. (Call me crazy but I’ve lived with 25 different people since high school and never had a really bad experience.)  Mr. Extreme Saver wins this one by $200, largely because he takes shared living to the next level by splitting a studio apartment with his wife.

Transportation: San Diego isn’t exactly known for its public transportation system so unlike Mr. Extreme Saver, I do have a car. But like Mr. Extreme Saver, I live in an area where I can walk around to almost everything I need (4 grocery stores, tons of restaurants, barber shops, banks, and even my doctor, dentist, and eye doctor are all in a short walking distance.) My car is also paid for so it only costs me $64 a month to insure and about $75 a month in gas since I don’t drive it much. Still, Mr. Extreme Saver has me beat here too by about $70.

Food, personal care, and entertainment: I personally lump together groceries, eating out, personal care, and entertainment under my $600 monthly cash allowance. Since I eat out a lot, this is my biggest weakness. I also know it’s not ideal from a health standpoint so I have a goal of cooking more and adding green smoothies into my diet. On the other hand, I rarely buy things or go drinking, clubbing, or to the movie theater so I spend less than my peer group in these areas. Even if you add his food, personal care expenses, and monthly cash allowance, Mr. Extreme Saver wins again by $135.

Health Care: Like Mr. Extreme Saver, my employer covers my health insurance premiums. However, since we have high-deductible insurance, and I’ve never met that deductible, I do end up paying practically all of my health costs out-of-pocket. I don’t count it as an additional expense though since my employer funds my HSA. I have Mr . Extreme Saver (slightly) beat here by $30-40 per year since he doesn’t have an employer-funded HSA for his co-payments.

Communication: I pay about $35 a month for 300 minutes and unlimited texts and data on an Android smartphone with Virgin Mobile, which uses Sprint’s network. While my monthly plan is actually only $25 a month, I spend about another $10 a month on overage charges. This is $20 more than Mr. Extreme Saver but having a a smartphone is definitely worth it to me, especially with all of my travel. It’s not an iPhone or the latest Android but I don’t need to be tempted by a slightly nicer screen to waste any more time playing Angry Birds.

Along with some other miscellaneous expenses, I round my total monthly spending up to about $1,500 so Mr, Extreme Saver wins by about $500 a month. I guess that’s why he’s called “Extreme.” Want to challenge us? If you’ve found a way to beat us in either a particular area or in total spending, leave a comment explaining how below.

 

More like this:

What’s Your Plan For a Financial Independence Day?

What’s Your Plan For a Financial Independence Day?

I personally think of financial independence as consisting of three different levels: ...
Read More
Which Federal Tax Breaks Still Apply To College Costs?

Which Federal Tax Breaks Still Apply To College Costs?

When it comes to education, most financial planning centers around saving and investing for college. This focus makes sense because ...
Read More
super bowl party with food

How To Throw A Money-Savvy Super Bowl Party

The Philadelphia Eagles will battle the Kansas City Chiefs for the Super Bowl Championship game on Sunday, Feb. 12th, 2023, ...
Read More

Subscribe

Be the first to know when new resources are published.