Common Financial Mistakes Parents Make By The Decade
March 05, 2019
Lately, I’ve had a lot of heartbreaking conversations with folks who are working hard to be the best parents that they can be and are really struggling to balance finances and parenting. What I have noticed is that it seems that there are recurring themes of money mistakes that parents make based on their age and stage of life.
As a dad myself, I get it. It is so hard to always be “on” and make the right decision. Perhaps by sharing some of the common mistakes we regularly see, I can help you avoid similar situations.
A top mistake parents make in their 20’s
Placing kids before career
Some of the most successful people I know had kids at a very young age. I’ve worked with many single parents who heroically balanced work and early parenthood to scratch their way to success. Often, the resilience and time management they learn in the process helps them later.
One super successful friend of mine started his family when he and his wife were 23 and in grad school. Today he is ranked as one of the 50 most influential people in the US in his profession. That said, they are the exceptions. My friend would tell you that the hardest times in his marriage were those years of school, work, parenting and living at the poverty level.
Without unbelievable willpower and a pretty great support system, most people don’t thrive when they start a family before they start the foundation of their career. That doesn’t mean you have to be in your dream job and have tons in the bank – just that you have put yourself on the right path.
How we avoided this mistake
My wife and I got married just a few weeks before I turned 23. She was a new nurse and as such, always had the night shift. I was still figuring out what I really wanted to do with my degree, so we decided to wait a few years to have kids. I’m so glad we did – 5 years later when we started our family, we were excited about the idea of having kids instead of worrying about how that would change things because we were both more settled in our careers.
I know that it may sound preachy and that isn’t my intent. But as we published in a recent Society of Actuaries essay – our research, and research of leading think tanks, shows that having a committed partner and a career path before a baby goes a long way towards long-term financial wellness.
A top mistake parents make in their 30’s
Not putting limits on kids’ activities
The hardest, but sometimes best, thing we can say to our kids is, “No.” However, in today’s crazy culture of over-scheduled kids, we sometimes don’t even let our kids say “No” because we get worried that they will miss out on something. As activities like sports, music, dance, etc. start at younger ages, sometimes we can forget that our kids haven’t even asked us about playing soccer, but here we are signing them up like their futures depend upon it.
I can’t tell you how many friends I have talked to over the years who have said something to the effect of, “When did our kids activities start running every minute of our lives?” Not only does this impact the time you have to spend with your spouse, your family, friends and even your kids – but it is expensive!
How we placed limits without our daughters hating us
My youngest daughter has been involved in cheerleading over the years and one of the things we had to say at one point was that once she got to high school she could no longer do competitive cheer. It just didn’t make sense to pay huge amounts of money for her to do an activity she was already doing at school, which also required us to drive half way across town two or more times a week (not to mention the cost and time of traveling to those competitions).
My daughter’s initial reaction was not good – she didn’t like it at all. But we stood our ground, then discussed how the money could be directed to other things important to her like vacation and her college fund. She eventually calmed down and I’m happy to report that a month or two into high school, she even said how glad she was to not be doing competitive cheer because she didn’t think she could balance that time commitment with everything else.
The moral of the story
It’s important to encourage your kids to try new things and discover their passions. But it is perfectly OK to set limits on your monetary and time commitment to anything – especially below the middle school level.
A top mistake parents make in their 40’s
Not putting limits on kids’ college choices
No matter where you get your news, you’re probably seeing the same thing we hear every day in talking with people about finances: student loan debt is financially killing people – students AND parents.
Sometimes student loans are unavoidable. My wife entered college right when her dad’s business hit hard times. She got some grants and worked a ton, but she still had to borrow about 1/3 of the cost of her education. That’s what the program was originally designed for – to get students over the final line.
Somehow over the years, costs have risen faster than incomes and more and more people are borrowing to fill the gap. That said, many people are focused on their “dream school” and not their return on investment for education. All education – from technical training to Harvard Law – is a great opportunity as long as you measure the expense against the benefit.
How we’re balancing this in our family
My oldest daughter is majoring in elementary education. She realized early on that our contribution would cover a state school, but she would have a ton of debt at most private or out of state schools. On a teacher’s salary that didn’t make sense, so she’s heading to a state school.
On the other hand, my youngest wants to major in supply chain management. She only has one in-state option in a new program or two nearby states have highly rated programs. Both of those out of state schools will offer her in-state tuition if she gets the ACT score she’s shooting for. Even if she gets a mediocre score, it would probably only mean borrowing about $10,000 – $14,000 for one of those top programs.
That is probably a good investment for a highly rated program. It’s worth noting that her “dream school” for her major would result in about $75,000 of debt or more. On a standard 10-year repayment that would mean an extra $638 per month for essentially the same degree! Needless to say, it’s not even on her list.
So, when talking to your kids about their post-high school education, don’t focus on the name or the cool campus – come at it from a longer-term perspective by setting a maximum amount of debt that jobs in their major can support and don’t go over that amount. A common rule of thumb is that total student loan debt upon graduation should not exceed the first year’s salary in your major’s field in order for the payments to be affordable. If at all possible, stay well below it!
A top mistake parents make in their 50’s
Helping adult kids at the expense of their own retirement
According to a recent study by Merrill Lynch, American parents are setting aside $250 billion annually for retirement while spending $500 billion per year helping their adult children! Think about that for a minute: using twice as much to help your adult kids as you’re using to help yourself.
According to the study, 79% of parents are helping their adult children and most alarming is that 25% of the time people are dipping into their retirement funds to do so. I get it, we all want our kids to succeed because we love them dearly. But I often describe it to people like what you hear from the flight crew before takeoff: if oxygen masks are deployed, put your own mask on first before assisting anyone else. The same concept applies here.
You don’t have to be independently wealthy to help your kids, but you should run a retirement calculation to make sure that you are on track for retirement and that the help you provide won’t jeopardize that. You also want to make sure that you are not making your kids dependent on you, but instead helping them to become self-sufficient. Then you’ll be able to enjoy knowing that not only are you going to be able to enjoy retirement but that you will be able to see your kids enjoy the help.
A top mistake parents make in their 60’s and beyond
Worrying about leaving something to the kids instead of caring for yourself
The last stage of mistakes I’ve seen parents make is worrying about running out of money – not for themselves but that they won’t be able to leave an inheritance to their kids. Of all the mistakes, this is probably the least frequent, but it is still very real and it makes me sad.
It is disheartening when someone works their whole life and then doesn’t do those “bucket list” things because they are worried about their kids again. What’s worse is that usually when I see this, it’s not a vacation that someone goes without but things that really impact their quality of life – I have seen my own family members not want to spend money on things like hearing aids, medical treatments or making accessible improvements to their homes so that they don’t “spend their kids’ inheritance.”
I don’t have a financial solution for this one but just some advice: Remember that your children and grandchildren love you and want you to be healthy and happy. They would rather see you enjoy the fruits of your labor and maintain your quality of life than get a few extra bucks after you are gone. Believe me, they tell me all the time in my line of work.