Ready To Move Out? How To Make It Happen In A Year Or Less

August 07, 2017

I recently spoke with, Dylan [not his real name], a 25-year old employee, when he called our Financial Helpline with a dilemma: he lived with his parents and siblings, and he really wanted to move out on his own. However, he was living paycheck to paycheck, paying his bills on time but spending whatever was left on enjoying life now. He liked his life, but he was starting to have a nagging feeling that it was time to get his own place. How much was it really going to cost, and how could he make it happen?

Step One: Follow the Money

When I asked him where he thought he was spending his money now, Dylan shared that he had monthly bills for his car, insurance, gas, parking, cell phone, gym membership and student loans, as well as contributing to family groceries. He had a spreadsheet in Excel where he figured out how much money he had remaining after paying bills every month. He generally spent whatever was left over, trying not to go in the red but otherwise not worrying about it.

Was it worth it to cut some expenses so he could get in his own place? The first step is to figure out what could be eliminated. I encouraged Dylan to track his daily expenses carefully to see where the money was going. We walked through different ways to do this, including using a smartphone app, the paper/pencil method, or entering them in a spreadsheet. Dylan already had Mint on his phone, but hadn’t set it up fully to easily track expenses, so he wanted to start with that method. I pointed him to Mint’s instructional videos on YouTube, and suggested a few to watch to make set up easier.

Step Two: Calculate the Costs of Renting

The next step was figuring out how much Dylan could afford to pay in housing costs, as well as how much it would take to rent an apartment. His paycheck was around $1,200 every two weeks after taxes, insurance and 401(k), so most months he was bringing home $2,400. If he spent no more than 35 percent of his take-home on rent and utilities, that would give him a total housing budget of $840.  He thought he would be able to get a small studio apartment for $800, or share a 2 BR with a friend for that amount.

So what would it take to move in?

He would need to come up with a security deposit of one month’s rent and the first month’s rent (about $1,600 total) when he signed a lease. Plus, if utilities were not included in the rent, since he had never had utilities in his name he may need to put down deposits for electricity and gas ($200). His parents had promised to give him some used furniture, but he would still need to get some household goods like dishes and a trash can, so we figured that was another $200. Rent on a do-it-yourself moving truck was $100. Altogether, he’d need to save at least $2,100 to move into his own place.

Step Three: Set Daily Savings Goals

I encouraged Dylan to set a daily savings goal. That would make it easier to say no to certain expenses. If he wanted to move out in three months, he’d need to save $705 per month or about $24 per day (see calculation here). If he wanted to get his own place in six months, he’d need to $355 per month or about $12 per day (see calculation here). If he took the long route and saved for a year, he’d need to save $180 per month or about $6 per day (see calculation here). Any of these goals seemed doable, given how low his current “must pay” bills were, so it depended on how much he was willing to make changes in his lifestyle in order to save.

Step Four: Pay Yourself First

If Dylan didn’t have easy access to those funds, he would be less likely to spend them. He had the capacity at work to have direct deposit to multiple accounts from his paycheck, so he decided to set up a savings account at his bank and have $180 per paycheck deposited automatically in it. That way, he concluded, he wouldn’t miss the savings so much. I encouraged him to find small daily expenses he could refuse regularly, such as the ones suggested in my blog post on ways to save money without changing your lifestyle.

Step Five: Check Your Credit

Dylan already had student loans and a car loan in his name and was making regular payments, so he had some credit history. That’s good news, as it’s harder to get a lease if you don’t have any credit information at all on your record. However, he didn’t know his credit score, so I encouraged him to check his actual credit reports online for free via annualcreditreport.com or to check his estimated score using Credit Karma or Credit Sesame.

The Middle Path

Dylan opted to try the six month savings plan. We set a time to check in two months from now for another coaching call, to see how it was going and if the $12 per day plan was realistic. If he implements his plan, he’ll be in his own place by next year!

Want more helpful financial guidance, delivered every day? Sign up to receive the Financial Finesse Tip of the Day, written by financial planners who work with people like you every day. No sales pitch EVER (being unbiased is the foundation of what we do), just the best our awesome planners have to offer. Click here to join.

Are You Ready to Buy A Home?

November 03, 2016

With all the speculation about interest rates possibly moving up soon, I’ve been hearing a lot of talk from people about buying a home. You may want to buy, but are you ready? The answer involves a lot more than what interest rates are expected to do. Here are some questions to ask yourself:

How’s your credit? If you’re planning to get a mortgage, one of the first things the mortgage company will do is run a credit check. To get the best rates, you typically need a score of 740 or above. If yours is lower, you’ll pay higher rates or you may not even qualify for a mortgage at all.

One of the quickest ways to improve your credit is to order a copy of each of your 3 credit reports from annualcreditreport.com (free every 12 months) and dispute any errors you may find that could be hurting your score. Another is to pay down credit card or other consumer debt, which also improves your debt/income ratio. If neither of these can improve your score in time, you may just have to build a positive record of on-time payments and wait for your score to rise over time.

Do you have enough savings for a down payment and closing costs? Ideally, you would have enough savings to put down 20% to avoid paying PMI, although mortgages with lower down payment requirements are available. You’ll also likely need another 2-5% of the purchase price for closing costs plus whatever you plan to spend on furniture, renovations, etc. This should be in addition to your emergency fund, which will be even more important with your home on the line.

Can you afford the higher payments? Contact a mortgage broker or loan officer to get a quote and see what your monthly payments would be with different purchase prices. Don’t forget to include estimated costs for insurance, taxes, utilities, and maintenance/repairs. Then see how this would fit into your current spending. It’s important to do this analysis before you even start looking at homes so you don’t fall in love with one and then talk yourself into being able to afford it.

Would buying be cheaper than renting? The rule of thumb is that you need to keep a home at least 3-5 years to make it worth the transaction costs and the risks of the home falling in value. You can do a more precision calculation with this Rent v Buy calculator from the New York Times that factors in everything from how long you plan to keep the home to the tax benefits of home ownership to the opportunity cost of not being able to invest the money you spend on the down payment. If you have a really good deal on rent, or home prices are particularly expensive, or you just don’t plan to stay put for long enough, renting may actually be more financially beneficial.

Are you ready emotionally? The numbers may make sense but they won’t matter if you don’t actually feel comfortable buying. Being a homeowner means freedom from a landlord but it also means being tied down to a home that you’re responsible for. No financial calculation can tell you if you’re ready for that.

 

Want more info on this or other financial topics? If you have a question you’d like answered on this blog, feel free to email me. You can also receive my future posts by following me on Twitter and/or subscribing to my posts on the blog home page.

 

 

Should You Buy or Rent?

August 11, 2016

This is a question I recently got on our financial helpline and one that I’m struggling with myself right now. The conventional wisdom is that renting is “throwing money away,” but owning a home also involves throwing away a lot more money than it may seem. One way to see this is by using a “Buy vs Rent” calculator like this one from the NY Times. Not only are you paying interest on the mortgage, there’s also maintenance costs, taxes, the opportunity cost of not being able to invest any extra money you put towards buying, and the transaction costs of buying and selling. Here are some things to consider before making one of the biggest financial decisions of your life:

How long do you plan to stay? For most people, this is probably the single biggest deciding factor. The longer you stay, the more buying usually makes sense because it takes time for the financial benefits to outweigh closing costs and real estate agent commissions, not to mention the risk that the home could actually be worth less when you try to sell it. It’s generally better to rent if you plan to stay less than 3-5 years.

What mortgage rate can you qualify for? To get the best mortgage terms, you typically have to have a credit score of at least 750 and put down 20%. If your credit isn’t so great or if you can’t make much of a down payment, you may want to delay buying until your credit or savings is in better condition.

Where would you invest any extra savings? If you can save more by renting and earn a good return on those savings, renting may be better. For example, if you’re not contributing enough to max your employer’s match, or have high-interest debt to pay down, or are just an aggressive investor, the return on your savings can be quite high.

What’s your tax bracket? The higher your tax bracket is, the more you can save by deducting mortgage interest and property taxes. Just be aware that you only benefit to the extent that these itemized deductions exceed your standard deduction.

How handy are you? As a homeowner, you won’t be able to call the landlord anymore when something needs to be fixed. If you can keep maintenance costs down by doing a lot of your own work or even by being a savvy shopper, buying might be more beneficial.

I’ve been renting, but I’m now considering buying a home. I should be able to qualify for a good mortgage rate and I’m in a moderately high tax bracket. On the other hand, I think I can also earn a decent return on my savings if I rent, and I’m not the most handy person.

The tie-breaker might be how long I would plan to live in my next home, which is a tough call that involves a lot of big life decisions. In the end, the decision to buy or rent often comes down to an emotional one. There’s nothing wrong with that as long as you’re aware and okay with the financial consequences as well.

 

Is It Better to Rent or Own?

February 09, 2016

One of the biggest questions I get when I talk to people is, “Is it better to rent or own?” I tell them that it is not as simple as a yes or no answer. The cost of living in your area, your area’s housing market, and your financial stability are all factors in deciding if renting or owning is the better decision. For some, renting temporarily is a better option but no matter what I say, I normally get the following rebuttals from those determined to buy a home now: Continue reading “Is It Better to Rent or Own?”

Should You Buy or Rent a Home?

June 11, 2015

Summer is often a popular time for people to buy a home. In fact, I was recently talking to an employee who wanted to buy a place but she noted that the mortgage payment would be more than the rent for similar priced homes in the area she was looking at. However, after looking at the tax breaks and possible home appreciation, we discovered that owning would actually be cheaper for her. Continue reading “Should You Buy or Rent a Home?”

How Many Toys Is Enough?

June 03, 2015

My neighbor down the street is selling his camper, and so my wife walks in the house the other day and says, “Honey, did you see the camper for sale down the street?” Now I love to camp, and to be quite honest, I was stunned she even asked the question. First of all, we already have a boat, and second, she’s not really a big fan of camping. To me, camping is about “roughing” it, but for my wife, she likes to “pamp,” (which is a word my friend made up that describes people who want to be pampered when they camp—thus the name). Continue reading “How Many Toys Is Enough?”

Rent vs. Buy: Seven Factors to Consider Before Buying a Home

June 25, 2014

Owning your own home has long been considered part of the American dream but as the housing market starts to heat up in certain areas of the country, home ownership may not be the most economical solution to housing.  A recent article in The New York Times draws attention to several factors that must be considered when evaluating the financial benefits of home ownership and provides a link to a Rent v. Buy Calculator* that potential homeowners can use to quantify the tradeoff. Here are some guidelines you can use when considering each factor: Continue reading “Rent vs. Buy: Seven Factors to Consider Before Buying a Home”

Do Your Own Credit Check Before You Rent

August 14, 2013

I knew I needed to have pretty good credit before I rented my home, but I never thought I’d have to check the credit of my landlord.  This was a lesson I learned several years ago after losing my security deposit to a landlord that eventually filed for bankruptcy. It all started six years ago when my wife and I moved to North Carolina. We were looking to purchase a home, but with so many on the market, we didn’t want to rush to buy, so we decided to rent for a few months. Continue reading “Do Your Own Credit Check Before You Rent”

Do Your Own Credit Check Before You Rent

July 24, 2013

I knew I needed to have pretty good credit before I rented my home, but I never thought I’d have to check the credit of my landlord.  This was a lesson I learned several years ago after losing my security deposit to a landlord that eventually filed for bankruptcy. It all started six years ago when my wife and I moved to North Carolina.  We were looking to purchase a home, but with so many on the market, we didn’t want to rush to buy, so we decided to rent for a few months.  Continue reading “Do Your Own Credit Check Before You Rent”

8 Home Buying Mistakes to Avoid

May 20, 2013

Exactly one year ago, our family completed a crosstown move in Charleston, South Carolina to get closer to family, my wife’s business, and our children’s schools, and thankfully, within a short little drive to Folly Beach. Any planned major purchase can add significant joy (and stress) as well as some expected and unexpected financial challenges and this was one was no different. Our new home was purchased through a short sale and although it was left structurally sound when we moved in there, there was a long to-do list related to cosmetic repairs, appliances in need of replacement, and an exterior in need of pretty significant landscaping and TLC. Continue reading “8 Home Buying Mistakes to Avoid”

Should I Rent or Buy?

April 14, 2011

For those of you who follow my recent posts, you are probably aware that my wife and I are re-locating to another state; in fact as I write this the movers are boxing up our possessions and will be loading up the moving van tomorrow.  Well I have to tell you, there is finality when you see your worldly goods packed in boxes by strangers!  What isn’t final (yet) is where my wife and I are going to call our new home. Continue reading “Should I Rent or Buy?”