Don’t Believe Everything You Hear
July 01, 2016I’m the kind of person who will always try to listen with an open mind to different points of view and find something to learn from the speaker. I hear a lot of theories that way, some which appear to be myths, superstitions or misinterpretations, and some of which offer a refreshing change in perspective. In many cases, what’s true for most people might not be true for everyone. When sifting through financial advice, make sure to ask yourself if that guidance makes sense for your situation. Here are three common examples of financial guidance where you might want to think about things differently:
Question: I’ve been told that I should always have a mortgage so that I can get the mortgage interest deduction. Is that always true?
My view on it: MYTH
For each $1 in interest they pay the mortgage company, the typical family gets ~$.20 in tax relief (using the tax rate as the real payback number). To me, you lose $.80 on the dollar by paying interest. Plus if you have no mortgage, your embedded cost of living is permanently lower, so your accumulated savings and investment dollars can last a whole lot longer. Financial advisors typically say disciplined, long term investors could do better in the stock market rather than using savings to pay off a mortgage, but I’ve observed that most people prefer to have the peace of mind that comes with low or no debt so I’m not a huge fan of carrying a mortgage just to get a tax deduction.
Question: I should never contribute more to my 401(k) than my company’s matching contribution. Once I reach that, I’m told I should open a Roth IRA. Is that the right choice?
My view on it: MYTH
Most people I see who try to implement this, forget one critical part – funding the Roth IRA. The problem with this guidance is that many people never get around to funding the Roth IRA every time they get paid. Once their paycheck hits their checking account, it gets accounted for in so many other ways. I’d prefer to see people shoot for the maximum 401(k) contribution ($18,000 this year, plus $6,000 in catch-up contributions for those over 50) and once they max out the 401(k), THEN contribute to an IRA.
Also, maxing out the 401(k) doesn’t have to be an instant thing. You can increase your contribution level by 1-2%/year until you get there. If you have a rate escalator in your plan, sign up for it today!
Question: If I close out some of my credit cards, that should improve my credit score, right?
My view on it: MYTH
Well, it’s not that simple! There are a lot of factors that go into your credit score. A few great places to see the multiple factors are CreditSesame.com and CreditKarma.com.
If the credit cards you want to close are relatively new, closing them may help you because it could increase your average “age of credit” (how long your open accounts have been open). But it may decrease your score because it reduces your overall credit limits and if you carry balances, it makes your “utilization ratio” higher. That’s the amount of overall credit balances divided by overall credit limit. Keeping that ratio below 25%, ideally at 0%, will be additive for your credit score. If closing accounts increases your utilization percentage, then closing the accounts can harm your score.
The thing to take away from this is that credit scores are fluid things. They change constantly. But if you take the time to review your scores and factors on the sites above, you will be able to make well informed decisions that impact your credit score.
As you go about living your life, learn how to discern the differences between good, solid personal financial management and misapplied financial principles. How? Ask a financial planning professional, pose a question on our Facebook page or ask me a question in the comments section below. Having the facts on your side can help save you from the many conflicting theories of managing your personal financial life.