Should You Close A Credit Card?
August 10, 2017One question we often receive is whether or not to close a card after it’s paid off or no longer in use. At first, your instinct might be to close the cards to avoid annual fees and perhaps to never face the risk of running that debt back up again. However, there are a couple of reasons why this can actually hurt your credit score.
Credit utilization
The first reason is that a big part of your credit score is your credit utilization or what percentage of your total credit limit you’re using. (It doesn’t matter if you pay off your credit cards each month because it’s measured at a random point in time.) Let’s say the total credit limit among all your cards is $10k and you have a $3k balance. In that case, your utilization would be 30%, the recommended max you should use to maintain the best credit score. If you close some cards and now have a total credit limit of $5k, that same $3k of debt would result in a 60% utilization.
Credit history
Of course, if you don’t use the cards anymore, your credit utilization will be zero no matter how many cards you have. There’s another reason why closing credit cards isn’t always a good idea though. Closing an old card can shorten your credit history, which is another factor in determining your credit score. So if the card you’re thinking of closing is your oldest card, you may want to keep it open just to keep that history active on your credit report.
This isn’t to say that closing cards is always a bad idea. If you have too many lines of credit, closing a few can actually help your score. To find out, you can use Credit Karma’s free Credit Simulator tool to see what the impact might be.
Alternatives to closing
If closing cards turns out to be a bad idea, there are some alternatives. If you’re worried about using the cards and running the debt back up, you can always physically destroy them or put them someplace hard to access, but keep the credit line open. If you’re trying to avoid fees, contact the card company and see if you can convert the card into one with no fees or one with rewards that outweigh the costs.
Measure the right things
Finally, don’t forget that credit scores are far from the most important number in your financial wellness. In fact, a few points here and there may make no difference at all in your ability to get a loan or the interest rates you qualify for. So despite what may be small impact on your credit score, sometimes the best choice is to just go ahead and close those cards.
Want more helpful financial guidance, delivered every day? Sign up to receive the Financial Finesse Tip of the Day, written by financial planners who work with people like you every day. No sales pitch EVER (being unbiased is the foundation of what we do), just the best our awesome planners have to offer. Click here to join.