Should You Follow Elizabeth Warren’s Money Management Advice?

While much of the country is discussing the president’s tax return, I stumbled upon an interesting article from a few years ago about the finances of one of the president’s possible opponents in 2020, Senator Elizabeth Warren. The article is titled “You, Too, Can Invest Like Elizabeth Warren” and is based on the information she submitted in a financial disclosure report along with tips from a financial planning book she wrote called All Your Worth: The Ultimate Lifetime Money Plan. Regardless of what you think of her politics, should you follow her financial recommendations? Before we get into the investing side next week, let’s take a look at the first set of recommendations called ”First Things First:”

1. Get debt free. Warren recommends that you “Drain your savings account, empty your checking account, and sell any stocks or bonds” to pay off all your debt. Warren herself has no debt except for a $15k student loan at 0% interest. In some ways, her advice makes a lot of sense. If you’re paying 18% interest on a credit card, paying it down is like earning a guaranteed tax-free 18% on your money and will also improve your credit score.

However, there are a couple of reasons why you might not want to “drain your savings account” to become debt-free. What if you suddenly find yourself in between jobs? You generally can’t put those mortgage or car payments on a credit card so now you risk losing your car and home. You can’t always rely on lines of credit either since they can be cancelled, especially if you’re unemployed or if the economy is weak. That’s why it’s always important to have some emergency savings (ideally enough cash to cover at least 3-6 months worth of necessary expenses) even before paying down high-interest debt.

Second, you might not want to pay off any debt balances early that have interest rates below 4-6% like many mortgages and student loans. That’s because you’re likely to earn more by investing that money instead. Perhaps that’s why Warren hasn’t paid off that  0% loan yet. This is especially true if you’re not contributing enough to your employer’s retirement plan to get the full match and leaving that free money on the table.

2. Don’t buy a sailboat if you work at Wendy’s (or are a journalist). What Warren really means is that 50% of your income should go to needs, 30% to wants, and 20% to savings. But how can you really separate “needs” and “wants?” Is your home a “need” because you “need” somewhere to live or a “want” because you’re paying extra for a really nice place you “want” in a great location? The same goes for everything from the car you drive to the food you eat.

This also seems like too much of a one-size fits all approach to me. Your spending and saving should be based on how you decide to balance your various personal goals and priorities. For example, I personally save a lot more than 20% of my income because achieving financial independence is a high priority of mine and I’m willing to live in a small studio apartment and not have a car to do it. If you work at Wendy’s and are willing to live with your parents and not spend much money so you can achieve your dream of buying a sailboat, go for it. As long as you understand and are willing to accept the trade-offs, do what makes YOU happy.

3. Pay off your mortgage if you have one. Mortgages tend to be low-interest and we already addressed the downside of paying off low-interest debt early, but mortgages have an additional benefit in that the interest is also tax-deductible. That means if you’re in the 25% tax bracket, a 4% mortgage costs you only 3% after-taxes so that’s the number you should consider when deciding whether to make extra payments. (You can calculate your mortgage tax savings here.) In fact, considering the low mortgage rates and the tax breaks, there’s even an argument for NEVER paying your mortgage off.

Of course, there’s much worse things you can do than getting debt-free, creating a money management plan, and paying off your mortgage. I just think her advice is overly simplistic. Next week, we’ll take a look at Warren’s investment advice…

 

More like this:

What’s Your Plan For a Financial Independence Day?

What’s Your Plan For a Financial Independence Day?

I personally think of financial independence as consisting of three different levels: ...
Read More
Which Federal Tax Breaks Still Apply To College Costs?

Which Federal Tax Breaks Still Apply To College Costs?

When it comes to education, most financial planning centers around saving and investing for college. This focus makes sense because ...
Read More
The No-Tracking Budget

The No-Tracking Budget

Putting together a budget is one thing, sticking to it is another ...
Read More

Subscribe

Be the first to know when new resources are published.