Should You Buy or Rent?

August 11, 2016

This is a question I recently got on our financial helpline and one that I’m struggling with myself right now. The conventional wisdom is that renting is “throwing money away,” but owning a home also involves throwing away a lot more money than it may seem. One way to see this is by using a “Buy vs Rent” calculator like this one from the NY Times. Not only are you paying interest on the mortgage, there’s also maintenance costs, taxes, the opportunity cost of not being able to invest any extra money you put towards buying, and the transaction costs of buying and selling. Here are some things to consider before making one of the biggest financial decisions of your life:

How long do you plan to stay? For most people, this is probably the single biggest deciding factor. The longer you stay, the more buying usually makes sense because it takes time for the financial benefits to outweigh closing costs and real estate agent commissions, not to mention the risk that the home could actually be worth less when you try to sell it. It’s generally better to rent if you plan to stay less than 3-5 years.

What mortgage rate can you qualify for? To get the best mortgage terms, you typically have to have a credit score of at least 750 and put down 20%. If your credit isn’t so great or if you can’t make much of a down payment, you may want to delay buying until your credit or savings is in better condition.

Where would you invest any extra savings? If you can save more by renting and earn a good return on those savings, renting may be better. For example, if you’re not contributing enough to max your employer’s match, or have high-interest debt to pay down, or are just an aggressive investor, the return on your savings can be quite high.

What’s your tax bracket? The higher your tax bracket is, the more you can save by deducting mortgage interest and property taxes. Just be aware that you only benefit to the extent that these itemized deductions exceed your standard deduction.

How handy are you? As a homeowner, you won’t be able to call the landlord anymore when something needs to be fixed. If you can keep maintenance costs down by doing a lot of your own work or even by being a savvy shopper, buying might be more beneficial.

I’ve been renting, but I’m now considering buying a home. I should be able to qualify for a good mortgage rate and I’m in a moderately high tax bracket. On the other hand, I think I can also earn a decent return on my savings if I rent, and I’m not the most handy person.

The tie-breaker might be how long I would plan to live in my next home, which is a tough call that involves a lot of big life decisions. In the end, the decision to buy or rent often comes down to an emotional one. There’s nothing wrong with that as long as you’re aware and okay with the financial consequences as well.